Expat Forum For People Moving Overseas And Living Abroad banner

Strange letter from IRS regarding 2555

180 views 6 replies 2 participants last post by  WizzDumbb  
Discussion starter
6 posts · ed 2025
Hello everyone. My partner and I recently went through the Streamline service with one of the big tax preparers. To note, we have a relatively simple tax situation, zeroing out on all of the past 3 years tax returns that we needed to submit.

We sent out our Streamline pack in March. However, we recently received a letter from the IRS relating to our 2021 return (dated April 17, which we thought was a pretty quick turnaround from reception to processing the return). The letter states that my partner and I need to file individual 2555s rather than a single 2555 combining out foreign earned income. However, we find this strange because we did, in fact, submit separate 2555 forms. We’re not really sure what to do, as we believe this is an error on their part.

We’ve ed our tax preparer, and they are confused as well. They said they had never seen this sort of thing before. They are going to write them a letter, but I’m worried that without knowing the exact reason why they sent out this letter, we could potentially be caught in a loop of back and forth with the IRS.

What’s even more frustrating is the letter noted that we had 30 days to respond, yet we received the letter just after the 30 day limit. They don’t indicate that we owe anything, rather that we just need to rectify the situation, but again, how do we rectify an issue when there isn’t an issue?

Just to note, I have not phoned the IRS as of yet. That was going to be my last port of call. I did, however, sign into my IRS portal, but I see no indication that my 2021 return was even initially processed, as there is no transcript, nor is there any indication that a letter was sent out.

We just find the whole thing a little strange and arbitrary. And also, how did our 2021 paper return go thru the process of initial checks so quickly? We are wondering if it maybe has to do with the fact that 2021 is the last year of stimulus checks, so are they perhaps trying to finalise those as quickly as possible? Who knows.

Thanks for reading. This has caused us a little bit of panic, so any advice is appreciated.
 
See less See more
When you say "partner" do you mean "spouse"? In which case, are both of you "US taxpayers" (US citizens) or are you availing yourselves of the choice of filing tly when one spouse is not subject to US taxation? I reckon your submission hit the IRS right about the time the DOGE-ettes were wreaking havoc on things there and it could be a big, stupid mistake. (Or, there is something else they are questioning, but they sent out the wrong form letter.)

If you are filing tly, this could relate to some glitch in the system - but at this date I really suspect that your submission has, at best, only been run through some computer scan to check for superficial issues. Do you have a copy of what you filed for 2021? (i.e. with both form 2555s)

First thing would be to notify the IRS by phone with follow up ed letter of the date their letter was received, indicating that you did file two 2555 forms and will be "happy" to resend the 2021 filing (or the whole packet, if they prefer). (Or first see if your tax preparer will help with this task or offer further advice.) Throws the ball back in their court for a while.
 
Hi Bevdeforges, thank you for your quick reply.

To answer your question, yes, my partner is my US spouse. We are both US citizens living in the UK, and were filing tly.

And yes, we have copies of the returns that were sent; the 2555s are clearly delineated between my forms and my wife’s forms.

It’s just a very odd situation, but we’re hoping it’s innocuous. Although, it has caused us some stress and worry, as we feel like we’re in the crosshairs.
 
Although, it has caused us some stress and worry, as we feel like we’re in the crosshairs.
Don't feel like the Lone Ranger here - with all the upheaval and chaos in the US these days there is a lot of that going around. The key thing is to respond calmly and ask for clarification (written is the better option) to resolve whatever the problem is. Chances are, it's a stupid mistake (like sending the "wrong" form letter) but you want to be on record as attempting to resolve whatever the problem is.
 
Thank you again for your reply. I really appreciate it.

So, just for clarity, is your advice to respond via letter for clarification, or would it be beneficial for us to try to get clarity first over the phone and then follow up with a letter/anything they asked for?

Another oddity that I noticed on my IRS portal, under refund status, it states that they received our 2022 return ($0 also owed, $0 refund, as expected). However, under tax transcripts / notices, it says that we still need to submit a 2021 and 2022 return. Perhaps it says that because it’s still in the process of being finalised. But just a strange discrepancy.
 
You may want to check with the tax preparer for their thoughts, but I think you could go with either approach. At the moment, you could spend a LONG time waiting on hold on the phone - and if that's the case, just start with the letter approach.
 
Post Reply